WD Green issues with Tivo Series 2?

[zigner]

I see you sell the WD 1TB Green drive for Tivo upgrades. I have read on several message boards about compatibility issues with this SATA drive with the Series 2 Tivo. Obviously a conversion card is required for SATA to IDE.

I have seen even more discussion about problems with these drives with series 3 Tivo's too (can't get past powering up screen). http://www.mfslive.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=438

I assume you have seen no issues with these drives with Tivo? Any idea why there is so much discussion with them not working in Tivo?

[WK-Michael]

We use the AV version of these drives - not the standard retail version. Our version shows none of those problems.